Defense rests in Oregon car-bomb plot trial

PORTLAND, Ore. (AP) - The defense team of an Oregon man accused of terrorism rested their case Tuesday after 10 days of testimony from witnesses, including undercover FBI agents, psychologists and the suspect's parents.
Mohamed Mohamud, dressed in a brown corduroy jacket, watched the final defense witness leave the stand late Tuesday afternoon in a Portland federal courthouse. Attorneys are expected to give closing arguments Wednesday morning.
The nine-woman, seven-man jury will decide whether Mohamud is guilty of attempting to detonate a weapon of mass destruction at a Portland Christmas tree-lighting in November 2010. His defense team contends that he was entrapped.
In support of their contention, prosecutors brought out the undercover FBI agents whom Mohamud thought were his jihadi co-conspirators. They each testified that Mohamud, 18 years old when they met him, conceived of and helped carry out the bomb plot.
Mohamud never hesitated, they testified, even when given a series of outs, and willingly pressed a button on a cellphone that he believed would detonate a 1,800-pound diesel-and-fertilizer bomb near 25,000 people at the tree lighting. The bomb was a fake placed there by the undercover agents.
Mohamud's defense team, relying on much of the same recordings of meetings and phone calls, along with text messages, contend that Mohamud couldn't have thought of the plan. He talked openly about violent jihad and privately expressed glee at 9/11, but had neither the will nor the means to commit terrorism.
On Tuesday, the defense called Dr. Marc Sageman, a former CIA officer who testified about al-Qaida before the 9/11 Commission in 2003. He testified that he reviewed Mohamud's communications with the undercover agents, and in his judgment, Mohamud was not a threat until the FBI met with him in person.
Before the undercover meetings, Mohamud had exchanged emails with an FBI source and with Samir Khan, an al-Qaida lieutenant killed in 2011 who led the group's effort to radicalize young men in the U.S. Mohamud's contact with Khan brought him to the FBI's attention.
But none of that contact ever amounted to a "furtherance of violence," part of Sageman's criteria for judging whether a person is likely to engage in terrorism.
One of the prosecution's central points is that Mohamud was clearly seeking contact with al-Qaida, and since he contacted Khan once, he could find another al-Qaida recruiter, or "spotter," again. Sageman contested that notion, saying there has never been a case of violence connected to terror groups in the U.S. that began with an al-Qaida recruiter or spotter.
"You've heard about these things," Sageman said, "but there is no evidence."
Earlier Tuesday, Elizabeth Cauffman, a professor of psychology at the University of California-Irvine, testified that recordings of the two undercover FBI agents show subtle attempts to convince Mohamud that the path to violence was the correct one.
Prosecutors say recordings of Mohamud agreeing to buy toggle switches and barrels to carry explosives are evidence that he was a willing participant in the plot. But Cauffman said that Mohamud had been conditioned by a system of reward, praise and prodding by the agents to agree with anything they said.
"They gave him the sense (that) they were authority figures," Cauffman said. "Adolescents don't want to seem like wimps."
Mohamud's brain likely wasn't fully developed at age 17, when he began attempts to reach al-Qaida, Cauffman testified. By age 18, Mohamud had fully-formed intellectual capabilities but was still emotionally immature and prone to risky decisions, Cauffman said.
Mohamud's age makes him among the youngest ever targeted by post-9/11 stings carried out by the FBI on suspected terrorists. He is now 21.
_____
Reach reporter Nigel Duara on Facebook at http://on.fb.me/127q7aU
Copyright 2013 The Associated Press.
If Islam is his religion, he is probably too dumb to understand what's he's done.
Just, wow.
This comment has been deleted
 @Dr. RawdogÂ
Â
Thank goodness nobody was hurt in the panic caused by the media reports that he allegedly tried to detonate a fake bomb created by the FBI in an imaginary plot engineered by the FBI.
Â
And, thank goodness that the Portland City Council rejoined the JTTF as a means to prevent these imaginary plots from happening in the future.  Look how well it is working: there have been no fake FBI terror plots in the past two years. Mission Accomplished...because Portland can't rejoin the JTTF twice.
If Mohamud is guilty, then Brandon Mayfield conspired to fly his fingerprints all the way to Madrid just to confuse the FBI lab techs in an attempt to help the real terrorists escape.
Â
And I'm hoping at least a few of the jurors remembered that fine piece of work by the Federal Bureau of Imbeciles.
Â
(Oh sorry, does that comment make me a terrorist?)
 @CopWatcher I'm sure they excluded anyone with a braincell from the jury.
If you build it- they will be killed
Was Major Nidal Hasan a expert psychiatric witness? or a brainwasher?Â
 @Bert Brainwashed. Interesting to find out he was on Bush's Homeland Security transition team, and had worked for the CIA for years, along side James Woolsey.
Â
Maybe a witness of sorts.
@vbg- this is much better- no advertisements blocking text
I wonder if the prosecution was able to get into evidence that "In 1991, he resigned from the agency to return to medicine. He completed a residency in psychiatry at the Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania. Since 1994, he has been in the private practice of forensic and clinical psychiatry and has had the opportunity to evaluate about 500 murderers." or that he lost a malpractice case for prescribing methadone to an ADD patient in Pennsylvania in 2002? One of the usual hired guns available for a price to the defense.
I would like to see the Jury instructions, please.  And, who will decide his penalty if he is guilty?
Â
Â
 @Icarus Sure as hell not you...
 @bonedÂ
Â
Angry much? Geez....no the point being that if the jury has several choices or lessor crimes then it would seem likely and reasonable that they would choose a lessor conviction rather than the whole terrorist kingpin charge that the FBI attempted to bluff.Â
Â
Then the second point is the penalty phase" if that is up to the judge or jury or if the case would then be held over for sentencing.Â
Â
Seriously, there were so many holes in the prosecution that it wouldn't surprise me if his punishment were time served and probation.  And, a justice department investigation into the FBI investigation. Â
Â
 @Rob C 503  @Icarus  @bonedÂ
Â
If you don't have doubts about the conduct of the FBI in this case then you're just not paying attention.  I wasn't at the trial but this FBI PLOT has smelled worse than a pig farm from the beginning and for two years I've payed attention to the news reports. And, during that two years the FBI has put on its best evidence and it only smelled worse.
Â
Since neither of us was on the jury we'll just have to accept the decision of the jury; agreed?
Â
And, I'm confident he won't hang or spend his life in jail. I'm confident the jury will see through all the B.S. and realize the FBI Plot for what it was.
Â
My only hope is that there will be a follow-up investigation of the FBI tactics and several agents will be at least reprimanded.
Â
Â
@Icarus @boned ......what do you think those "holes" were? Did you attend the trial? I wish I could have.
Can we lock him in a room with a real suicide vest and his attorneys and psychologist to see if they are correct or not?
 @FreedomRocks Sure... Provided we can include the F.B.I. agents who led him down this path..
I really cringe when I read the entrapment defense...... NOBODY BUT MOMO pushed the button (repeatedly) trying to kill possibly hundreds if not thousands of people ......
Â
IMHO it will be a total disgrace to the city if MOMO walks..... well, on second thought Portland may just be weird enough to be proud of something like that..Â
Â
If MOMO walks,  it will make Portland a  sancturary city for terrorists in addition to being a sanctuary city for illegals.
 @kramr So you seem to find it okay for the agents to give this boy cash ? they did..
You think it's okay that this boys father called and wanted the help of the F.B.I. , since he suspected his son was being led down a bad path, and they continued to lead him down that path..
These were adults who led a child down this path, yes he was a mess, but without them do you feel this boy would have done this ? I don't think so.. If I were on the jury I would have a hell of a time getting beyond these findings.. Maybe you should imagine this being do to your child ...
"Kids" dont just seek out al-qaida and try to get involved in some sort of terrorist activity. The FBI wasnt even concerned with this kid until he took that step, they don't just target random middle eastern people and try to convince them to bomb stuff. AND anyone who "privately expressed glee at 9/11" should be banned from this freaking country. All you liberal, overly sensitive, idiots need to wake up and realize that at 17-18 you are PLENTY adult enough to know whether or not its okay to get involved in TERRORIST ACTIVITY THAT WOULD HAVE KILLED THOUSANDS OF INNOCENT PEOPLE. All you idiots defending this as*hol* need to wake the heck up and start using your brain. So all the murders who killed at 16 shouldnt be tried as adults then either, right? GET A GRIP
 @kramr You must be bored. - Portland already is all of those...
Entire civilizations are built and wars waged from old men manipulating young men. Â With the promise of respect and glory from their state or religion young men have the ability to do anything. Â Then when they get old and realize what little they have achieved, their obvious target is to manipulate the next generation of young men to do their bidding... a never ending cycle. Â Meanwhile the women of the world are spending their lives wondering what the hell is wrong with all the men.
Go have some more peanut butter! Put some rutabaga on it also.
 @jpkÂ
Â
Yes, because Vietnam was a righteous war. And the Iraqi thing was totally cool even if it was an illegal military action justified by the lies of old wealthy men and resulting in the deaths of thousands of innocent people and hundreds of young Americans that were either maimed or killed.  The cost of that illegal war was more than a trillion dollars and will encumber the American economy for decades but it was totally worth it anyway....just ask Halliburton, Blackwater, Brown & Root, and the other contractors on cost plus no bid contracts.
 @jpk  @IcarusÂ
Â
The quote being responded to was:Â "...wars waged from old men manipulating young men."Â Â Which was a point of agreement and further illustration that it isn't just "young men" that are manipulated on the basis of lies but entire societies too and, typically, to grievous, irrational, costly, and deadly ends.
Â
In this case of the "FBI Christmas Tree Plot", a young man was manipulated to be the fall-guy in an FBI plot intended to manipulate the Portland City Council to rejoin the JTTF.Â
Â
The FBI plot was pretty simple: plan an extravagant plot, engage the right brown stupid kid, select a high profile location, reveal the plot to the media. Pretty simple to do really given the endless FBI budget and the terror hysteria whipped up by FAUX and everyotther news outlet.
Â
The thing that I find really curious is that many of the people who refuse to acknowledge or even consider that this 17 year old kid may have been in anyway manipulated or that the public may have been manipulated by the FBI claim, at the very same time, that the media is conspiring to manipulate the the American people in a rush to ban guns following the emotional tsunami of Sandy Hook. Just as it was with the Patriot Act and Homeland Security and the TSA this is true; I agree the American people are again being manipulated to believe that their Constitutional Rights are a problem because they endanger American safety.Â
Â
The difference is that I'm not a bleeding heart liberal or a gun nut conservative; I simply think for myself and I'm intellectually consistent. Intellectually inconsistency always demonstrates an irrational allegiance to some external belief system or social identification or it is the result idiocy or mental illness...or a combination of all three which is very common.
Â
Â
@Icarus Yup! Hindsight is always 20-20, isn't it? What has that got to do with this young terrorist on trial right now?
@Icarus @jpk Paranoid much I think
As reported in the press..........his parents were so afraid of him, THEY. Called the FBI in 2009 !
 @Rob C 503Â
Â
Afraid for him...there is a difference. Placing him on a no-fly and monitoring him would have been enough. Clearly he wasn't in touch with any terrorist cell in Eugene and a kid that wasn't able to rent a storage locker without coaching by the FBI couldn't represent a credible threat.Â
"By age 18, Mohamud had fully-formed intellectual capabilities but was still emotionally immature, Cauffman said, easily manipulated and prone to risky decisions."
Â
That's pretty much the case with most 18 year olds. Find a troubled one and you can manipulate him into doing just about anything, including terrorism. Doesn't mean that the kid would have done it if left alone. In fact, it's unlikely. He'll be found guilty, but this was entrapment and will one day be recognized as such.
 @Max Quinn I'm hoping a Portland jury has the brains to recognize this as entrapment and find this young man not guilty... Once the father called the F.B.I. for help is all it would have taken for me as a juror. Very sad story..
Hope so, but remember the jury is of his peers!
 @jpk Does that mean they all will be wearing suicide vests on the jury panel?
@dougrpdx .....your rationalization is what sad.
I didn't want to be a wimp when I was a kid and probably did some stupid things. However, hooking up with a terrorist organization with the thought of killing a bunch of innocent people was not one of them. As for having damage to his prefrontal cortex, I think the defense Attorney needs to have his checked.
It is PROVEN the FBI can frame ANY seriously mentally ill kid!
@August100 And you got this from the microchip in your head, right?
@August100 .....okay, show us the proof you're citing.
 @Rob C 503  @August100Â
Â
If everyone would take their blinders off and read something other than MSM you wouldn't need everyone to explain it for you. Â Research it yourself.
 @Rob C 503  @IcarusÂ
Â
I have a feeling that you're going to blow a gasket when the jury finds this kid innocent of the most insane charges and only find him guilty of being gullible.
@Icarus ......time to take your happy pills and join mankind !
 @Rob C 503  @justanopionionÂ
Â
You're the last one that should complain about unsubstantiated statements/conclusions....that's all that you can muster is emotional hostility.
@justanopionion .......when someone makes a claim I expect them to support it facts, not opinions. How do you know I haven't researched it? I want to see if the poster has!
 @Rob C 503  @August100Â
 @August100 Just wait until you tw-ts give up your means of protecting yourself from them.Guys like you aren't going to have a whole lot of people coming out to defend you.
 @Playanekes  @August100Â
Â
Who is "them"? Are "they" everywhere? Do "they" follow you? What have "they" done to threaten you; do you have people coming out to defend you?
Given enough money, defense can always find a psychologist to say whatever they need them to say. Would you call that "manipulation" of the criminal justice system?
 @jpkÂ
Â
And the FBI had enough money to set up an elaborate plot to manipulate the Portland City Council into rejoining the JTTF and to hoodwink this stupid kid into being the fall-guy.
 @jpk Exactly and these same psychologist regularly declare mentally ill cured only to have them go out and commit some heinous crime. So clearly this is just a guessing game for them and they really have no idea what's going on in the brain of those they analyze for sure.