Inside NYC's huge underground construction project

NEW YORK (AP) - Sixteen stories below Grand Central Terminal, an army of workers is blasting through bedrock to create a new commuter rail concourse with more floor space than New Orleans' Superdome, just one of three audacious projects going on beneath New York City's streets to expand what's already the nation's biggest mass transit system.
But even with blasting and machinery grinding through the rock day and night, most New Yorkers are blithely unaware of the construction or the eerie underworld that includes a massive, eight-story cavern, miles of tunnels and watery, gravel-filled pits.
"I look at it and I'm in wonder, I'm in awe," says engineer Michael Horodniceanu, president of capital construction for the state Metropolitan Transportation Authority. "I feel like when I went to Rome and entered St. Peter's Basilica for the first time. ... I looked at it and said, 'Wow, how did they do that?'"
In New York, they hauled out so much rocky debris from under Grand Central that it could have covered Central Park almost a foot deep, Horodniceanu says.
Together, the three projects will cost an estimated $15 billion. And when they're all completed, tentatively in 2019, they will bring subway and commuter rail service to vast, underserved stretches of the city, particularly the far East and West sides of Manhattan.
"They'll be a game-changer for New Yorkers," says Horodniceanu, an Israeli-educated native of Romania who lives in Queens.
The most dramatic project will result in a sort of 21st century, underground Grand Central Terminal mirroring the century-old Grand Central Terminal above -a 350,000-square-foot, $8.3 billion commuter rail concourse with six miles of new tunnels. It will accommodate Long Island Rail Road trains that now bypass Manhattan's East Side as they roll east through Queens and straight to Pennsylvania Station on the island's West Side.
This so-called East Side Access will bring about 160,000 passengers a day from Long Island to a new station in Queens' Sunnyside neighborhood, then about five more miles to the new, eight-track Grand Central hub.
For now, the subterranean hub is a drippy, humid construction site. The raw, dark gray walls mark the dimensions of the future concourse - eight stories high, about 70 feet wide and 1,800 feet long, or about "five football fields, without the end zones," Horodniceanu says.
The Federal Transit Administration is kicking in $2.7 billion toward the estimated $8.3 billion budget, with the MTA state agency covering the rest using mostly taxpayer money.
Also under construction is the Second Avenue Subway that eventually will serve Manhattan's far East Side, from Harlem to the island's southern tip. The planned eight miles of track will open Manhattan's East Side to millions of people who now squeeze daily onto the Nos. 4, 5 and 6 subway trains running under Lexington Avenue.
Dubbed the "The Line That Time Forgot," the Second Avenue Subway has been a New York City dream since the 1920s. Then came the Great Depression and World War II, followed by lack of funds that stopped the project after several stretches of tunnel with tracks were built in the 1970s. The existing tunnels are now being incorporated into the new ones.
The first phase - 1.7 miles with stations between East 63rd and East 96th streets - is to be completed in 2016 at a cost of $4.5 billion. Funding and plans for the rest of the route are still up in the air.
Finally, there's the extension of the No. 7 subway line from Times Square to a huge new real estate development on Manhattan's Far West Side, New York's biggest besides the World Trade Center. It's called Hudson Yards, a small urban village of high-rises, parkland, retail businesses and cultural institutions in the West 30s.
Moody's Investors Service calls this subway extension - financed through $2.1 billion worth of city-issued bonds - "a key milestone towards attracting development."
"These are vital projects, and they'll reinforce the infrastructure of the city," says Mitchell Moss, director of the Rudin Center for Transportation Policy and Management at New York University. "It's not just about people going to work; the New York subway and rail systems are busy 24 hours a day, taking people shopping, to theaters, to clubs."
The city's 468 subway stations register more than 1.6 billion rides a year. The system is used by more than 5 million daily riders. The Metro in Washington, D.C., has about 800,000, and San Francisco's Bay Area Rapid Transit has about 400,000.
The three mammoth projects require creative solutions and the latest technology.
When crews prepared to drill the giant new cavity under Second Avenue, they first had to freeze the ground to about minus 20 degrees so as not to destabilize the buildings above as the boring machine cut through. For that, aluminum tubes were inserted from the street and a special chemical solution was poured into the ground and cooled by a refrigeration plant.
The Second Avenue tunnels hold a space-age surprise: The ceilings are coated with a material once used to fireproof the space shuttle.
The new line has another major improvement. Instead of ventilation grates that allow rainwater to pour in, the new stations will be aired using enclosed cooling plants. When Superstorm Sandy hit the city last October, floodwaters washing over the East Side did not penetrate subway construction sites.
"We're using the best technology available today, but this is really people-intensive work," says Horodniceanu, who supervises a team of thousands of workers on any given day.
"I feel I have the most exciting job in the world," he says. "It's an incredible feeling to be able to build a legacy project. I hope that one day, my grandchildren will be able to say their granddad built this!"
But even with blasting and machinery grinding through the rock day and night, most New Yorkers are blithely unaware of the construction or the eerie underworld that includes a massive, eight-story cavern, miles of tunnels and watery, gravel-filled pits.
"I look at it and I'm in wonder, I'm in awe," says engineer Michael Horodniceanu, president of capital construction for the state Metropolitan Transportation Authority. "I feel like when I went to Rome and entered St. Peter's Basilica for the first time. ... I looked at it and said, 'Wow, how did they do that?'"
In New York, they hauled out so much rocky debris from under Grand Central that it could have covered Central Park almost a foot deep, Horodniceanu says.
Together, the three projects will cost an estimated $15 billion. And when they're all completed, tentatively in 2019, they will bring subway and commuter rail service to vast, underserved stretches of the city, particularly the far East and West sides of Manhattan.
"They'll be a game-changer for New Yorkers," says Horodniceanu, an Israeli-educated native of Romania who lives in Queens.
The most dramatic project will result in a sort of 21st century, underground Grand Central Terminal mirroring the century-old Grand Central Terminal above -a 350,000-square-foot, $8.3 billion commuter rail concourse with six miles of new tunnels. It will accommodate Long Island Rail Road trains that now bypass Manhattan's East Side as they roll east through Queens and straight to Pennsylvania Station on the island's West Side.
This so-called East Side Access will bring about 160,000 passengers a day from Long Island to a new station in Queens' Sunnyside neighborhood, then about five more miles to the new, eight-track Grand Central hub.
For now, the subterranean hub is a drippy, humid construction site. The raw, dark gray walls mark the dimensions of the future concourse - eight stories high, about 70 feet wide and 1,800 feet long, or about "five football fields, without the end zones," Horodniceanu says.
The Federal Transit Administration is kicking in $2.7 billion toward the estimated $8.3 billion budget, with the MTA state agency covering the rest using mostly taxpayer money.
Also under construction is the Second Avenue Subway that eventually will serve Manhattan's far East Side, from Harlem to the island's southern tip. The planned eight miles of track will open Manhattan's East Side to millions of people who now squeeze daily onto the Nos. 4, 5 and 6 subway trains running under Lexington Avenue.
Dubbed the "The Line That Time Forgot," the Second Avenue Subway has been a New York City dream since the 1920s. Then came the Great Depression and World War II, followed by lack of funds that stopped the project after several stretches of tunnel with tracks were built in the 1970s. The existing tunnels are now being incorporated into the new ones.
The first phase - 1.7 miles with stations between East 63rd and East 96th streets - is to be completed in 2016 at a cost of $4.5 billion. Funding and plans for the rest of the route are still up in the air.
Finally, there's the extension of the No. 7 subway line from Times Square to a huge new real estate development on Manhattan's Far West Side, New York's biggest besides the World Trade Center. It's called Hudson Yards, a small urban village of high-rises, parkland, retail businesses and cultural institutions in the West 30s.
Moody's Investors Service calls this subway extension - financed through $2.1 billion worth of city-issued bonds - "a key milestone towards attracting development."
"These are vital projects, and they'll reinforce the infrastructure of the city," says Mitchell Moss, director of the Rudin Center for Transportation Policy and Management at New York University. "It's not just about people going to work; the New York subway and rail systems are busy 24 hours a day, taking people shopping, to theaters, to clubs."
The city's 468 subway stations register more than 1.6 billion rides a year. The system is used by more than 5 million daily riders. The Metro in Washington, D.C., has about 800,000, and San Francisco's Bay Area Rapid Transit has about 400,000.
The three mammoth projects require creative solutions and the latest technology.
When crews prepared to drill the giant new cavity under Second Avenue, they first had to freeze the ground to about minus 20 degrees so as not to destabilize the buildings above as the boring machine cut through. For that, aluminum tubes were inserted from the street and a special chemical solution was poured into the ground and cooled by a refrigeration plant.
The Second Avenue tunnels hold a space-age surprise: The ceilings are coated with a material once used to fireproof the space shuttle.
The new line has another major improvement. Instead of ventilation grates that allow rainwater to pour in, the new stations will be aired using enclosed cooling plants. When Superstorm Sandy hit the city last October, floodwaters washing over the East Side did not penetrate subway construction sites.
"We're using the best technology available today, but this is really people-intensive work," says Horodniceanu, who supervises a team of thousands of workers on any given day.
"I feel I have the most exciting job in the world," he says. "It's an incredible feeling to be able to build a legacy project. I hope that one day, my grandchildren will be able to say their granddad built this!"
So anyone else expecting a Balrog to show up in that photo?
The photos accompanying this story remind me of a sci-fi futuristic time. With all the recent concerns about rising sea-levels and the flooding after the last storm to hit NYC, I wonder about the future success of this expensive project. Admittedly, Manhattan Island was scrubbed down to bedrock after the last glaciers left thousands of years ago, but still, I would be concerned about periodic flooding. As for the vaunted pumps that are in use daily to keep "normal seepage" out of the subway tunnels, what would happen if there were an extended power outage? But then again, I no longer live in NYC and don't have to commute into and out of Manhattan anymore. I would just hope that those responsible for this expensive project thought this out really well, and have backup plans to fall back on. Â
Oregon should jump on the High Speed Rail system now because the cost will increase exponentially with time as the windows of opportunity close and land and access must be seized by emanate domain.
Â
And, a high speed train connecting Eugene-Salem-Portland would be the best means of overcoming the traffic/parking problems that prevent Oregon from hosting any world class major league sports team. And, it would be a great alternative to driving South for those big State game....PARTY TRAIN! WOOT!  Think about it knuckleheads...I mean sports fans. C'mon....I kid my friends in body paint who buy $15 "we're #1" foam fingers and get drunk on $7 beer.
No wonder why we have a fiscal cliff problem!
 @portlandborn83Â
Â
Yeah...right? They just keep digging holes.
Â
That's the problem with public transportation it just costs everybody too much money; New York was so way better in 1889, before the subway system, when everybody was driving horses.Â
WOW!
Â
NO Wait! Didn't the whole subway system just flood? Aren't we experiencing sea level rise? Hmmm does this make any sense? Anybody not know the ice is all melting?
 @Gwen Boucher Exactly
The cover photo looks just like Boston's big dig. (I took a tour way back) It's new that built up cities go underground?  Portland's big sewer projects use state of the art boring machines to cut under streets and houses.
Non grade mass transit. Been done for two hundred years.
Â
But for some r-tarded, backward, and traffic clogging (not to mention weather stopping) reason, Portland put ALL of its mass transit choices at grade.
Â
Want light rail? Well you will have to bulldoze homes, businesses and block traffic for 3 years while we build it, then deal with the traffic jams it will create stopping traffic every time it goes by.
Â
Want short rides? Well guess what, you get to sit in traffic on streetcars just like the people in cars, only you have to stop every 55 feet to pick up passengers. Nice ride huh?
Â
How about a freeway? Those are great, too bad you need to level entire areas, cut neighborhoods into pieces and have pollution pile up in people's backyards. Not to mention you will never be able to widen or improve it because that would mean bulldozing more homes and businesses. Those are real popular.
Â
Portland's mass transit express concepts would ACTUALLY BE EXPRESS if we put it below grade.
Â
It works great all over the world, but not for Portland, oh no, we have to SEE outr mass transit and have it block views of the river, keep people from getting places by car and force businesses to move so we can have it placed prominently in front of us.
Â
Because we all know how pretty everything to do with mass transit is.
Â
Â
There is more earthquake activity in the NW than in NYC. As for building things underground in NYC, they have had more time to get that infrastructure built at a time years ago, when labor and materials were cheaper. Portland can't even get power and phone lines underground now, even though every year there are outages because of trees freezing with branches falling on the lines. Â
@Repoman at the same time tripling or quadrupling the price of the projects.
 @Ramsesthegreat  @RepomanÂ
Â
Yes, isolate the cost of the West Side tunnel and compare the cost of that section per mile to the cost of tracks above grade. If Portland tried to build below grade New Yorkers would hear the collective whine.Â
Â
Tubes make more sense in NY, Paris, London where real estate is at a premium but most of the world's public transportation infrastructure is primarily above grade.Â
Â
The key is to establish the routes and easements early to prevent future placement issues. L.A. is spending a half-billion dollars just doing a feasibility study for public rail transportation because the completely eliminated every remaining trace of their extensive rail and cable car system in the 1940's. BART in S.F. is primarily above ground and does a great job of connecting the larger Bay Area.
 @Repoman Spot on. Spot on!