Boy, 2, mauled to death after falling into zoo exhibit
PITTSBURGH (AP) - A mother's attempt to give her 2-year-old son a better view of wild African dogs turned into a fatal tragedy after the boy fell into the exhibit and was attacked by a pack of the animals as relatives and bystanders looked on.
The mother had picked the child up and put him on top of a railing at the edge of a viewing deck at the Pittsburgh Zoo late Sunday morning, Lt. Kevin Kraus of the Pittsburgh police said.
"Almost immediately after that he lost his balance, fell down off the railing into the pit, and he was immediately attacked by 11 dogs," Kraus said. "It was very horrific."
It's not yet clear whether the boy died from the fall or the attack, said Barbara Baker, president of the Pittsburgh Zoo & PPG Aquarium. Zoo officials at first estimated the boy fell 14 feet, but police said it was 11. It's not clear which is correct.
The Allegheny County medical examiner planned an autopsy Monday, and the boy's name was not expected to be released until that was complete.
Authorities said that zoo staff and then police responded "within minutes," but visitors described that time as being filled with screams for help. Zookeepers called off some of the dogs, and seven of them immediately went to a back building. Three more eventually were drawn away from the child, but the last dog was aggressive and police had to shoot the animal.
Steve Feldman, a spokesman for the Association of Zoos and Aquariums, said no one he's spoken to can recall any deaths of children at an accredited zoo over the last 40 years or more. Feldman said the Pittsburgh Zoo successfully completed its 5-year review in September, which means it meets or exceeds all safety standards.
Authorities didn't release the name of the woman, but say she is 34 years old and lives in Pleasant Hills, just outside Pittsburgh. The boy's father arrived on the scene soon after the accident, police said.
The zoo was immediately closed, and it was not clear when it will reopen, authorities said.
The so-called painted dogs are about as big as medium-sized domestic dogs, and 37 to 80 pounds, according to the zoo. They have large, rounded ears and dark brown circles around their eyes and are considered endangered.
The attack happened in a 1.5 acre exhibit called the Painted Dog Bush Camp that's part of a larger open area where elephants, lions and other animals can be seen. Visitors walk onto a deck that is glassed on the sides, but open in front where the roughly four-foot railing is located.
In May, some of the dogs crawled under a fence and escaped into a part of the exhibit that's usually closed. The zoo was on lockdown for about an hour as a precaution.
Past fatal attacks at have prompted zoos around the nation to review safety features of their exhibits. In 2007 a tiger jumped over a wall at the San Francisco zoo, killing one visitor and wounding two others. Authorities first said the wall was 18 feet high, but a review found it was just 12 ½ feet.
In September a man jumped off an elevated viewing train at the Bronx Zoo in New York and was severely mauled by tigers.
Kraus said there was nothing to prevent visitors to the painted dog exhibit from jumping into the exhibit area.
Police and the Allegheny County medical examiner's office are investigating, and they haven't yet interviewed the mother and father, who are receiving grief counseling.
Baker said the zoo, which has never had a visitor death, will also investigate. She said no decision has been made yet on the future of the exhibit.
The mother had picked the child up and put him on top of a railing at the edge of a viewing deck at the Pittsburgh Zoo late Sunday morning, Lt. Kevin Kraus of the Pittsburgh police said.
"Almost immediately after that he lost his balance, fell down off the railing into the pit, and he was immediately attacked by 11 dogs," Kraus said. "It was very horrific."
It's not yet clear whether the boy died from the fall or the attack, said Barbara Baker, president of the Pittsburgh Zoo & PPG Aquarium. Zoo officials at first estimated the boy fell 14 feet, but police said it was 11. It's not clear which is correct.
The Allegheny County medical examiner planned an autopsy Monday, and the boy's name was not expected to be released until that was complete.
Authorities said that zoo staff and then police responded "within minutes," but visitors described that time as being filled with screams for help. Zookeepers called off some of the dogs, and seven of them immediately went to a back building. Three more eventually were drawn away from the child, but the last dog was aggressive and police had to shoot the animal.
Steve Feldman, a spokesman for the Association of Zoos and Aquariums, said no one he's spoken to can recall any deaths of children at an accredited zoo over the last 40 years or more. Feldman said the Pittsburgh Zoo successfully completed its 5-year review in September, which means it meets or exceeds all safety standards.
Authorities didn't release the name of the woman, but say she is 34 years old and lives in Pleasant Hills, just outside Pittsburgh. The boy's father arrived on the scene soon after the accident, police said.
The zoo was immediately closed, and it was not clear when it will reopen, authorities said.
The so-called painted dogs are about as big as medium-sized domestic dogs, and 37 to 80 pounds, according to the zoo. They have large, rounded ears and dark brown circles around their eyes and are considered endangered.
The attack happened in a 1.5 acre exhibit called the Painted Dog Bush Camp that's part of a larger open area where elephants, lions and other animals can be seen. Visitors walk onto a deck that is glassed on the sides, but open in front where the roughly four-foot railing is located.
In May, some of the dogs crawled under a fence and escaped into a part of the exhibit that's usually closed. The zoo was on lockdown for about an hour as a precaution.
Past fatal attacks at have prompted zoos around the nation to review safety features of their exhibits. In 2007 a tiger jumped over a wall at the San Francisco zoo, killing one visitor and wounding two others. Authorities first said the wall was 18 feet high, but a review found it was just 12 ½ feet.
In September a man jumped off an elevated viewing train at the Bronx Zoo in New York and was severely mauled by tigers.
Kraus said there was nothing to prevent visitors to the painted dog exhibit from jumping into the exhibit area.
Police and the Allegheny County medical examiner's office are investigating, and they haven't yet interviewed the mother and father, who are receiving grief counseling.
Baker said the zoo, which has never had a visitor death, will also investigate. She said no decision has been made yet on the future of the exhibit.
I cannot believe she wanted anything to happen to the child (in this day and age anything is possible) but if not she feels worse than anyone who has not lost a child can ever know. Then to know in part you are responsible for what happened because of a bad choice, I think she will punish herself more than any one else will ever be able todo. I feel so sad for her pain I know it all to well but not due to a pack of wild dogs.Nothing wrong with a zoo but if a child can slip through or a stupid adult can jump over the fence then both zoo staff and idiot people are to blame. I hope she does not sue she will lose so much empthy and sympthy.
@2little2late But the child didn't 'slip through', they were lifted OVER the barrier. My heart absolutely breaks for this mother as I can't imagine standing there watching this unfold, but the zoo didn't do anything wrong. They had signs, barriers, safety measures...this mother, probably out of pure intentions to show her child a good time, chose to ignore all safety precautions and tragedy struck. However, there is personal responsibility that needs to be taken here. The zoo didn't do anything wrong and I too hope she doesn't sue. I also hope she gets the grief counseling she'll need because she will live with this over and over and over again for the rest of her life. I don't wish that on anyone, especially over one poor decision.
As a mother and grandmother I simply cannot understand why anybody would place a child - let alone a squirmy 2 year old toddler - on a fence in a zoo? Pick the child up into your arms or set him on your shoulders for better view....but placing him on a fence? Did she want the child to fall? Ggggrrrr.....
I can understand helping a species that are on the brink of extinction (and NOT displaying them for entertainment).. but taking wild animals and locking them up, or caging them up, for all to observe is disgusting.   We as humans are disgusting.    Karma plays a big role in fatal zoo accidents, so have fun visiting the local jail for animals. I am sure they love their caged habitat. Sick.
@MrAchilles 99.9% of zoo animals now days are born in captivity. They have no chance of every surviving in the wild. At least in the zoo they are cared for, have medical treatment, proper nutrition and a comfy place to make 'home'. What would you like to do to all of the zoo animals? Simply kill them all? Or release them into the wild and have nature take care of it?
@MrAchilles Need a tissue?
You cannot fathom any of it - parents do negligent acts all the time. It's only this time - it is so surreally horrific. The image of wild dogs - who don't know nor can they be expected to know - the difference between a steak or a child - when it id dropped down right in front of all of them. All they know - is prey occured in that pen, they are wild animals - and they reacted - as wild animals predictably and CYCLE OF LIFE guaranteed will.Â
Â
In the blink of an eye what was supposed to be a happy time at the zoo - turned into a horror show. And worst of all - a young boy lost his life - horrifically. No child deserves that. NONE.Â
Â
It was wrong. And pens should be absolutely and completely closed off to any entry point - even "entry points" that are high up over the top of a pen... I will be looking over the Oregon Zoo with a critical eye for these lapses in securing pens they have too - soooooo sad..Â
Zoos lately have been redoing their enclosures to permit a "more open" style that is more realistic to the animals native habitat. I submit that this is a mistake, and accidents like this are bound to happen in such an exhibit, unless there is more of a buffer space so that people cannot come into contact with the anuimals in the enclosures if they fall.
Another case of excessive stupidity. Hope the mother fries.
You read stories like this, where 34 year old moms put 2 year olds on railings and you honestly wonder just how stupid are we?
Â
Â
What's even more sad is the fact that the mother will probably file a lawsuit against the zoo for her stupidity. Which in turn will lead to higher admission fees for the public.
 @JLO And some giant glass barrier so that you can't just gaze down at the animals anymore, but have to look through a dirty window.
Â
Pittsburgh police Major Crimes Lt. Kevin Kraus said the boy's 34-year-old mother placed the child in a standing position on a wooden railing overlooking the enclosure.
"Almost immediately after that he lost his balance, fell down off the railing into the actual pit and he was immediately attacked by 11 dogs," Lt. Kraus said.
Lt. Kraus said zoo personnel responded within minutes. The first personnel on scene were able to lure seven of the dogs away from the victim and into a secure and separated area. A second set of personnel began "throwing objects and some other techniques that they use" to secure three more dogs.
He said the final dog, which was acting very aggressively toward the victim and zoo personnel, was shot multiple times by two Pittsburgh police officers and died.
Lt. Kraus said none of the people who observed the child fall into the enclosure made an attempt to go after him. The news release from zoo officials noted that keepers attempted to enter the yard but were unable to reach the child.
One ineffective technique used by zoo personnel to lure the animals away from the child was to fire "dummy tranquilizer rounds," Lt. Kraus said.
Â
Just How Can a 2 yr old enter an Exhibit ? Sounds to me like the Zoo is at fault also, you have to make these places IDIOT Proof or you can bet something like this Will happen. And was there any Real Men there ? Everybody watching and Nobody Doing anything to possibly keep the dogs off the child ? Maybe he was dead from the fall but that will be determined at the autopsy....
 @Glenn Pierce The 2YO "entered" the exhibit due to the ignorance of his Mother placing him on the railing surrounding it.  The Zoo is not at fault for being an attraction to a breeder who should've never been allowed to parent in the first place.
Well   KATU  Changed the whole story from earlier and left the older comments that dont fit the new story........TKANKS  KATU.....good job again.........
Hopefully the fall killed him instantly and the little guy didn't have to feel the dogs. RIP
This headline really bothers me. " Child killed after fall" I realize after ready the story that the wild dogs may have killed him. Wouldn't something more like "Child dies after fall", be more accurate, and sound less as if some person killed him?
@Yamhill354  Actually....his mother killed him.....why did she have to put him onto that fence?? I certainly know she didn't mean to do that, but come on. It clearly was her fault. But you watch...the zoo will be blamed because the fence wasn't high enough, or some other drivel. How many caution signs need to be put up before parents think about what they're subjecting their children to?
how sad. parents fault.
 @mstercor How do you know that? That's a pretty cold and insensitive comment.
@scoreboard @mstercor So...his mother used common sense in putting him on top of that fence???? Obviously she didn't mean for this horrible thing to happen...but what was she thinking???? At the very least, if she put him up there, why wasn't she holding onto him better to keep him from falling??? Good grief parents can be so ignorant. In essence, yes..she killed him.
 @fracas  @scoreboard Well excuse the you know what outta me. Before KATU changed the story there was nothing in it that indicated what happened.Â
So sad, what a tragedy all the way around.
Just How Can a 3 yr old enter an Exhibit ? Sounds to me like the Zoo is at fault also, you have to make these places IDIOT Proof or you can bet something like this Will happen. And was there any Real Men there ? Everybody watching and Nobody Doing anything to possibly keep the dogs off the child ? Maybe he was dead from the fall but that will be determined at the autopsy....We took our children to many different Zoo's and kept a weather eye on them every second. Sad....
@Glenn Pierce Did you graduate Special Ed with honors? Find me anybody that'll jump into a cage with a pack of wild dogs and I'll show you somebody with a deathwish.
 @Glenn Pierce I read somewhere else that the parent was lifting the child up over the barrier so he could see better.
Â
If that is the case, I do not believe the zoo is at fault. Stupid people will always find a way.
 @WhenCowsAttack  @Glenn Pierce WCA, sounds like you may be right, I saw another story that reported this:
Â
"WTAE reporter Ashlie Hardway tweeted that her sources say a mother was holding her 3-year-old son up to see the African painted dogs and he leaned forward and fell in."
Â
If true, I don't see how the zoo should be held responsible for what followed. I still feel horrible for the family and others who witnessed the horrific event, regardless of who is responsible.
So sad, some parent was not watching their child. It only takes a second.
 @dkgiovenco I read elsewhere that the parent was lifting the child up so he could see better.
 @WhenCowsAttack  Darn, that even make it worse, way to go parents. Talk about feeding your kids to the Wolves, this parent did.
And I am sure that the mom is heartbroken about it - she will have to live with this for the rest of her life - so don't be too hard on her.