South Korea's porn fight 'like shoveling in a blizzard'

SEOUL, South Korea (AP) - Moon Tae-Hwa stares at his computer, dizzy and nauseous from the hours of porn he's viewed online while his wife and children slept. He feels no shame - only a righteous sense of mission.
"I feel like I'm cleaning up dirty things," the devout Christian and family counselor said.
Moon is among the most successful members of the "Nuri Cops" (roughly "net cops"), a squad of nearly 800 volunteers who help government censors by patrolling the Internet for pornography in their spare time.
Unlike most developed nations, pornography is illegal in South Korea, though it remains easy for its tech-savvy population to find. More than 90 percent of South Korea's homes have high-speed Internet access, and more than 30 million of its 50 million people own smartphones.
"It's like shoveling snow in a blizzard," Moon conceded.
But while there is no chance the government will wipe out porn, it also shows no sign of giving up the fight. In fact, it has responded to several recent high-profile sex crimes with a fresh crackdown.
More than 6,400 people accused of producing, selling and posting pornography online were arrested over a six-month period ending in late October.
"Obscene materials and harmful information that can be easily accessed on the Internet are singled out as one cause inciting sex crimes," President Lee Myung-bak said in a radio address in September.
Free-speech advocates disagree with the government's unrelenting stance.
"It's a reign of terror against sex," Ma Kwang Soo, a Korean literature professor at Seoul's Yonsei University and author of a book that South Korea banned because of its sexual content. "No country in the world has ever reported that banning porn results in a drop in sex crimes."
Reported sex crimes have risen sharply over the past decade in South Korea, though researchers with the state-run Korean Institute of Criminology have said they believe the biggest reason is that victims have become more willing to report abuse.
The institute said more than 18,000 people were arrested on rape charges in 2010, up from less than 7,000 in 2000. Sex crimes against minors, meanwhile, more than quintupled, from about 180 cases in 2000 to about 1,000 in 2010, according to the Ministry of Gender Equality and Family.
Critics of South Korea's stance note that when it comes to child pornography, which is banned virtually everywhere, the country's laws have been relatively soft. Possessing child porn brings a maximum one-year prison sentence, and until recently had been punishable by just a fine.
South Korea has a history of censorship nurtured by decades of military-backed rule that ended only in the late 1980s. It also has a large and active conservative Christian population and a deep-rooted strain of Confucian morality. Yet it has also become one of the world's most technologically advanced countries.
Censorship of movies, songs and news media has gradually eased since South Korea achieved democracy, but the government blocks foreign websites containing pornography and shuts down those operating within South Korea.
The job seems endless, however, so police turn to the Nuri Cops, who include university students, information technology workers, professors and housewives.
"Police officers can't look at all the obscene material online, so their role, which is reporting illegal sites that need to be blocked, is very important," senior police officer Lee Byeong-gui said of the volunteers.
Over two weeks in August, the squad reported more than 8,200 cases of online porn during a police-organized contest.
Police say they have recently shut down 37 websites, and another 134 sites are under investigation on porn-related charges. Authorities also deleted many porn materials from other websites, though Moon said much of the porn re-emerged in slightly different form days after being removed.
Some Nuri Cops acknowledge that they are fighting an increasingly difficult battle against a relentless enemy. They've also faced complaints from their sometimes baffled spouses and friends, and endured venom from anonymous online porn enthusiasts.
"They've called me the enemy of South Korean men," Bae Young Ho, a Nuri Cop who works as a real estate broker, said of his online critics. He said he found about 5,000 malicious messages attacking him in the comments section of an online story about his work.
The volunteers also find the work itself to be disturbing.
"It's easy to find smut on the Internet, but it's difficult for me to watch," Moon said in an interview at his Seoul home. "It's disgusting and it bothers me because the images I see linger in my head for so long."
Moon, who was ranked the top anti-porn monitor in 2010 and second this year, said he and other Nuri Cops keep going because they feel that society benefits from their work.
Opponents of pornography point to several recent horrifying sex crimes as reasons to try to stamp it out.
A man was sentenced to life in prison this year for strangling a woman after a failed rape attempt, then chopping her body into 280 pieces that he hid in plastic bags at his home south of Seoul. The man told investigators he watched pornographic movies while cutting up the victim's body.
Another man got a life sentence for strangling a 10-year-old girl living in his neighborhood after a failed rape attempt. He was found to have dozens of child porn films in his computer.
South Korean law punishes those who distribute, sell or display obscene materials on the Internet with up to one year in prison. There's no punishment for watching or possessing cyberporn.
The National Assembly recently passed a law raising - from seven years to 10 years - the maximum sentence for distributing, selling or displaying child pornography for commercial purposes. Legislators also made possessing child pornography punishable by up to a year in prison; previously, the maximum punishment had been a fine of 20 million won (about $18,500).
The prime minister's office says it will seek to have all movie download sites and smartphones used by minors equipped with anti-porn filtering systems. Anti-porn campaigners also want authorities promote sex-education programs aimed at countering the effects of pornography among children.
Some South Koreans believe the government's approach should be more nuanced. Lee Bong Han, a former police officer who teaches at Deajeon University, said it's time for South Korea to legalize less extreme and nonviolent pornography, which he believes can be used in clinics that treat sex problems.
Ma, the professor who advocates for porn legalization, doubts that such changes will come anytime soon. He sparked a national debate in the early 1990s after authorities arrested him and banned his book "Happy Sara," about a female university student exploring her sexual freedom.
"It's been 20 years since I was arrested ... but South Korean culture hasn't democratized yet," Ma said.
"Happy Sara," he added, is still banned.
"I feel like I'm cleaning up dirty things," the devout Christian and family counselor said.
Moon is among the most successful members of the "Nuri Cops" (roughly "net cops"), a squad of nearly 800 volunteers who help government censors by patrolling the Internet for pornography in their spare time.
Unlike most developed nations, pornography is illegal in South Korea, though it remains easy for its tech-savvy population to find. More than 90 percent of South Korea's homes have high-speed Internet access, and more than 30 million of its 50 million people own smartphones.
"It's like shoveling snow in a blizzard," Moon conceded.
But while there is no chance the government will wipe out porn, it also shows no sign of giving up the fight. In fact, it has responded to several recent high-profile sex crimes with a fresh crackdown.
More than 6,400 people accused of producing, selling and posting pornography online were arrested over a six-month period ending in late October.
"Obscene materials and harmful information that can be easily accessed on the Internet are singled out as one cause inciting sex crimes," President Lee Myung-bak said in a radio address in September.
Free-speech advocates disagree with the government's unrelenting stance.
"It's a reign of terror against sex," Ma Kwang Soo, a Korean literature professor at Seoul's Yonsei University and author of a book that South Korea banned because of its sexual content. "No country in the world has ever reported that banning porn results in a drop in sex crimes."
Reported sex crimes have risen sharply over the past decade in South Korea, though researchers with the state-run Korean Institute of Criminology have said they believe the biggest reason is that victims have become more willing to report abuse.
The institute said more than 18,000 people were arrested on rape charges in 2010, up from less than 7,000 in 2000. Sex crimes against minors, meanwhile, more than quintupled, from about 180 cases in 2000 to about 1,000 in 2010, according to the Ministry of Gender Equality and Family.
Critics of South Korea's stance note that when it comes to child pornography, which is banned virtually everywhere, the country's laws have been relatively soft. Possessing child porn brings a maximum one-year prison sentence, and until recently had been punishable by just a fine.
South Korea has a history of censorship nurtured by decades of military-backed rule that ended only in the late 1980s. It also has a large and active conservative Christian population and a deep-rooted strain of Confucian morality. Yet it has also become one of the world's most technologically advanced countries.
Censorship of movies, songs and news media has gradually eased since South Korea achieved democracy, but the government blocks foreign websites containing pornography and shuts down those operating within South Korea.
The job seems endless, however, so police turn to the Nuri Cops, who include university students, information technology workers, professors and housewives.
"Police officers can't look at all the obscene material online, so their role, which is reporting illegal sites that need to be blocked, is very important," senior police officer Lee Byeong-gui said of the volunteers.
Over two weeks in August, the squad reported more than 8,200 cases of online porn during a police-organized contest.
Police say they have recently shut down 37 websites, and another 134 sites are under investigation on porn-related charges. Authorities also deleted many porn materials from other websites, though Moon said much of the porn re-emerged in slightly different form days after being removed.
Some Nuri Cops acknowledge that they are fighting an increasingly difficult battle against a relentless enemy. They've also faced complaints from their sometimes baffled spouses and friends, and endured venom from anonymous online porn enthusiasts.
"They've called me the enemy of South Korean men," Bae Young Ho, a Nuri Cop who works as a real estate broker, said of his online critics. He said he found about 5,000 malicious messages attacking him in the comments section of an online story about his work.
The volunteers also find the work itself to be disturbing.
"It's easy to find smut on the Internet, but it's difficult for me to watch," Moon said in an interview at his Seoul home. "It's disgusting and it bothers me because the images I see linger in my head for so long."
Moon, who was ranked the top anti-porn monitor in 2010 and second this year, said he and other Nuri Cops keep going because they feel that society benefits from their work.
Opponents of pornography point to several recent horrifying sex crimes as reasons to try to stamp it out.
A man was sentenced to life in prison this year for strangling a woman after a failed rape attempt, then chopping her body into 280 pieces that he hid in plastic bags at his home south of Seoul. The man told investigators he watched pornographic movies while cutting up the victim's body.
Another man got a life sentence for strangling a 10-year-old girl living in his neighborhood after a failed rape attempt. He was found to have dozens of child porn films in his computer.
South Korean law punishes those who distribute, sell or display obscene materials on the Internet with up to one year in prison. There's no punishment for watching or possessing cyberporn.
The National Assembly recently passed a law raising - from seven years to 10 years - the maximum sentence for distributing, selling or displaying child pornography for commercial purposes. Legislators also made possessing child pornography punishable by up to a year in prison; previously, the maximum punishment had been a fine of 20 million won (about $18,500).
The prime minister's office says it will seek to have all movie download sites and smartphones used by minors equipped with anti-porn filtering systems. Anti-porn campaigners also want authorities promote sex-education programs aimed at countering the effects of pornography among children.
Some South Koreans believe the government's approach should be more nuanced. Lee Bong Han, a former police officer who teaches at Deajeon University, said it's time for South Korea to legalize less extreme and nonviolent pornography, which he believes can be used in clinics that treat sex problems.
Ma, the professor who advocates for porn legalization, doubts that such changes will come anytime soon. He sparked a national debate in the early 1990s after authorities arrested him and banned his book "Happy Sara," about a female university student exploring her sexual freedom.
"It's been 20 years since I was arrested ... but South Korean culture hasn't democratized yet," Ma said.
"Happy Sara," he added, is still banned.
The fact that he watches porn isn't hurting anyone, not even his family  since they are asleep. Hopefully it doesn't carry over into his work life.
I bet Moon Tae-hwa likes what he see's...Ohhhhh
Haha. I've been living in Korea for 3 years. This story is true. The government has been blocking quite a few websites lately. They don't just block porn, but also other websites such as some online pharmacies. A warning screen will popup.
Â
Anyway, there are a lot more things they could be doing instead of banning online pornography. Sex shops and sex saunas are EVERYWHERE here. Kids probably walk past them every day while on their way to school. Also, most sex crimes will not be prosecuted because they are within the home. And the legal system is very soft here.
Â
Just a week or so ago, a 29 year old public school teacher had sex with a 12 year old student. What happened to the teacher? Nothing. Because the 12 year old girl "loved" the teacher and didn't want anything to happen to him, they didn't prosecute.
When my wife catches me looking at internet porn I tell her "I'm learning where it is so I can prevent the kids from going there"
Â
Â
 @deejm2112 If the porn fight is like shoveling in a blizzard, I bet he gets a lot of snow on his hands.
In the meantime, when I was doing his sort of work, we looked for fraud, identity theft, stolen social security numbers, spammers, jihadist websites, and child porn.
Â
...Surfing the internet for pictures of naked women would have been much more pleasing but if people think that it's the worst thing on the internet, I can tell you about having to witness a baby rape video, or the expression a little boy makes as he's executed in the street of Fallujah alongside his father.  Because that crap exists on the internet and if South Korea thinks a Playboy picture is the real problem, as far as I'm concerned we should let North Korea have them.
Â
The images DO linger in your head for a long time, but this guy is just looking at porn in, you know, the privacy of his own room.Â
"nearly 800 volunteers who help government censors "Â Wow what a cr@phole... I bet our police state would love a snitch squad like that.... oh wait there are dozens of alphabet agencies here whose job is to crush freedom.
 @FrankCastleÂ
Â
Yeah because the antithesis of peace is law and order.
Â
There is a difference between competent and draconian.
Â
What draconian law enforcement agency broke your door down and took your stuff?
Tito, get me a tissue!
@Pointblank Or an old sock....
 @Pointblank"Moon Shot" ...no race to the moon, though, just a happy ending...:)
Is that a smile of disgust on his face?
 @Pointblank He wasn't talking about the exploitation of women by voyeurs photographing up their dress and sharing it on the internet... I mean, as long as she's wearing panties.... No, he was talking about PORN. You know, couples having sex for example? Adult women and men voluntarily modeling for compensation or entertainment? Girls willingly exposing their breasts in public the way men sometimes do, and all that disgusting stuff?
Â
(Usenet feeds and NNTP servers were CRUSHED by amateur porn long before there were pay sites.)
Â
Sure looks like a smile to me. Some people call it "shoveling in a blizzard" but others call it "surfing porn and ratting out your sources so you can keep getting away with it."
"hours of porn he's viewed online" That's what I do with my spare time too, watch hours of porn. To combat it of course... yeah that's exactly what I'm doing. Moon Tae-Hwa needs a better hobby, or maybe just more tissue.
 @JTeslaÂ
Â
Yeah i thought of the same thing.
Â
"I am helping stop it!"
Â
Yeah, right dude.
@Repoman @JTesla As long as I don't have to touch his keyboard, he can do whatever he wants.
Anyone who has a family member who is addicted to porn can tell you how horrible that stuff really is. It isn't "freeing", it is a chain and shackle, and the person becomes combative about it.Â
Â
Many will disagree, but I can only state from my family's experience. It's a waste of time.Â
 @washcomomÂ
Â
Porn as an addiction is like any addiction, an issue with the addict.
Â
Not that a "blame" addicts for their addiction, but many people have predilection to become addicted to something and sometimes that thing is porn.
Â
I used to go to the URS club (lots of family addicts). Where AA and NA "survivors" would hang out "sober". They would chain smoke and sleep with anything that had a pulse. Alcohol and meth were replaced with sex and cigarettes. Some gambled like crazy.
Â
You cannot combat meth use by incarcerating meth addicts for 10 years. You cannot stop porn from being decimated by putting the website maker behind them either. You need to get people "addicted" to something that benefits themselves and/or others.
@Repoman@washcomom "Porn as an addiction is like any addiction, an issue with the addict."
Â
So is the quest for power and control over the freedom of other individuals. In Japan you can show a teenager being raped on a train as long as you blur out the genitalia, because, that makes it obscene in their culture.
Â
Regardless, Japan and Korea don't have remarkably different lifestyles, crime problems or social issues. Their only real threat is that Weeble nutsack to the North.
 @washcomom Any addiction is a a chain and shackle, agreed. Lots of folks aren't addicted to porn, and while I think it's a waste of time, I don't see why it should be illegal. If these folks dedicated their efforts to "patrolling" child porn it would be a much better use of resources.